Back to Blogs

    Are You Struggling to Let Go of the Role That Got You Promoted?

    CCindy Cohen
    May 14, 2026
    Are You Struggling to Let Go of the Role That Got You Promoted?

    The identity that earned you the seat is often the one the seat asks you to put down.

    I saw a quote on a window the other day.

    When I let go of who I am, I become.

    The original is commonly attributed to Lao Tzu, and the full version reads slightly differently. When I let go of what I am, I become what I might be. I prefer the truncated one. It promises no destination. It just leaves you with becoming.

    For leaders, this turns out to be more practical than it sounds.

    The identity that got you here

    Most of us carry an identity that got us here. The expert who knew the technical answer. The operator who outworked the room. The founder who held the original vision. These identities were earned. They were the engine of the success that put us in the seat we now hold.

    When the seat asks for something else

    But the seat eventually asks for something else.

    • The expert promoted to CEO cannot keep being the smartest person in the room without quietly draining the room of intelligence.
    • The operator promoted to head of strategy cannot grind harder and call it leadership.
    • The founder past two hundred people cannot remain the originating mind on every decision.

    The thing that got us here is often the thing that keeps us from getting there.

    Why identity is hard to put down

    Identity, when it is working, is invisible. It only becomes visible when you try to put it down. That is when most leaders discover they do not want to.

    There are good reasons for that.

    • It is where your confidence lives. The expert knows the answer. The operator knows the work gets done because they do it. That certainty took years to build, and the new role rarely offers anything as solid in return, at least at first.
    • It is how other people know you. Your team, your peers, and your board learned to rely on a specific version of you. When you change how you show up, some of them will pull you back toward the old pattern, often without meaning to.
    • It is what you reach for under pressure. On a calm day, it is easy to delegate the decision or let someone else find the answer. On a hard day, the old identity is faster, and it has a track record. Stress pulls most of us back to what worked.

    Underneath all three is loss. Letting go of an identity you earned can feel like losing something before it feels like gaining anything. Many leaders read that discomfort as a sign they are doing it wrong. More often it is a sign they have started.

    What remains is becoming

    There is no fully formed next self waiting. The work is letting go of the specific role-shaped self that has fused with the current role.

    In practice, letting go is small and repeated.

    • Asking a question when you already have the answer. You give the room a chance to think, and you learn what your team sees that you don't.
    • Letting a decision get made without you. Some will go differently than you would have chosen. Many will turn out fine, and the team gets stronger each time.
    • Noticing the pull. When you feel yourself reaching for the old move, pause long enough to choose. Sometimes the old move is still right. The point is that it becomes a choice.

    None of this produces a new identity on a schedule. You keep practicing, and over time the old self loosens its grip. What fills the space is responsive to what the moment needs.

    That is what the quote on the window gets right. It stops at "I become." It leaves room.

    What remains is becoming. No object. No destination.

    That is the work.

    Questions leaders ask about leadership identity and transitions

    What does it mean to let go of your identity as a leader?
    It means loosening your grip on the version of yourself that earned the role so you can do what the new role asks. You keep the skills. What changes is how much of your sense of self depends on them.

    How do I know my identity is holding me back?
    One sign is reaching for the move that used to work and finding it no longer fits. Answering every question yourself, outworking the team, staying in every decision. When the people around you start waiting on you to think, it's worth a look.

    Can a coach help with a leadership transition?
    Transitions are a common reason senior leaders bring in a coach. A coach can help you see which parts of your old identity still serve you and which are getting in the way. If you're weighing whether coaching fits your situation, our guide Considering Executive Coaching walks through how to decide.

    About the Author

    Cindy Cohen, MBA, PCC, coaches directors, VPs, and C-suite leaders, most often in tech, through the moments that matter, and is the founder of Alefitt, which matches senior leaders with vetted executive coaches.

    Subscribe