Back to Blogs

    How Do You Handle Disagreement at Work?

    CCindy Cohen
    February 05, 2026
    How Do You Handle Disagreement at Work?

    Three words can lower the stakes in a tense conversation and bring clarity back.

    There's a moment in disagreement when you stop listening and start preparing your response.

    That's when clarity leaves.

    Most of us try to correct the other person's thinking. We explain. We persuade. We defend. The smarter we are, the better we get at this and the worse we get at understanding.

    Where Smart Leaders Get Stuck in Disagreement

    Senior leaders are often rewarded for making a strong case. You build the argument, anticipate the objections, and bring people along. Those skills help in a pitch or a board meeting. In a disagreement with a peer or a direct report, they can work against you.

    The pattern is easy to miss from the inside. While the other person is still talking, part of your attention has moved to your rebuttal. You hear their first point, decide where it goes wrong, and wait for an opening. By the time you respond, you are answering the version of their view you predicted, which may be different from the one they hold.

    The other person usually senses this. They push harder, you push back, and the conversation turns into two people defending positions.

    Three Words That Change the Conversation

    Three words change the dynamic. Tell me more.

    Said sincerely, it signals that you want to understand the person in front of you before you try to move them anywhere.

    The phrase works because it interrupts the pattern on both sides. You stop rehearsing. They stop bracing. For a moment, the goal of the conversation shifts from winning to learning what the other person sees. This is active listening in its simplest form.

    What Curiosity Does in a Tense Conversation

    Curiosity lowers the stakes. People stop defending and start opening. You begin to hear what sits underneath the position.

    • Their reasoning. The logic that led them here often includes steps you skipped or weighed differently.
    • Their assumptions. Many disagreements trace back to different starting beliefs about the market, the team, or the timeline.
    • Their experiences. A past project that failed, or a manager who burned them, can shape a view more than any data point.

    Once you can see these layers, the disagreement usually gets smaller. You may find you agree on more than you thought, and that the gap sits in one assumption you can test together.

    How to Say "Tell Me More" So It Lands

    The words matter less than the intent behind them. If you say "tell me more" while waiting to pounce, people will hear it as a tactic, and the conversation can get worse.

    A few habits help the phrase do its work.

    • Pause before you say it. A beat of silence tells the other person you are making room for them.
    • Follow up on what you hear. Ask about the part of their view that surprised you most. That shows you were listening and keeps the thread going.
    • Resist the urge to rebut right away. When they finish, reflect back what you understood before you offer your own view.
    • Listen longer than feels natural. The most useful part of someone's thinking often comes after their first answer.

    Understanding Without Agreeing

    You still may not agree. But now you understand. And understanding is where better decisions come from.

    Leaders sometimes worry that listening this way signals agreement or weakness. In practice, it tends to do the opposite. When people feel heard, they are more willing to accept a decision that goes against them, because they trust it was made with their view in the room. You also make the decision with better information, since you know where the risks and objections sit.

    How Coaching Helps Leaders Listen Under Pressure

    Listening is easy when the stakes are low. It gets harder when the topic touches your judgment, your team, or your reputation. A coach can help you notice the moment your attention shifts to defending, and practice staying curious a little longer. Over time, leaders often find that the tightening they feel in a hard conversation becomes a cue to listen instead of a cue to argue.

    The next time you feel that tightening in a conversation, pause and say, "Tell me more."

    Clarity often returns when you listen longer than feels natural.

    Questions Leaders Ask About Handling Disagreement at Work

    How do I stay calm when someone disagrees with me?
    Notice the physical signs first, such as a tight chest or the urge to interrupt. Treat them as a signal to slow down. A short pause and a question like "tell me more" gives you a moment to steady yourself while the other person keeps talking.

    What if I still disagree after listening?
    That's fine. Listening helps you understand the other view, and you can still decide differently. Say what you heard, explain your reasoning, and name where you landed. People accept disagreement more easily when they can see their view was considered.

    Does "tell me more" work with my boss as well as my team?
    Yes. With a boss, it can help you understand the pressures and priorities behind a decision before you push back. With your team, it shows that you value their thinking, which makes them more likely to speak up next time.

    What can I ask besides "tell me more"?
    Try "What am I missing?", "How did you get there?", or "What worries you most about my approach?" Each one invites the other person to share their reasoning and keeps you in listening mode.

    Can an executive coach help me handle conflict at work?
    Yes. A coach can help you spot your patterns in hard conversations, practice staying curious under pressure, and prepare for disagreements that matter. If you are weighing whether coaching fits where you are as a leader, our guide, Considering Executive Coaching, is a practical place to start.

    About the Author

    Cindy Cohen, MBA, PCC, coaches directors, VPs, and C-suite leaders, most often in tech, through the moments that matter, and is the founder of Alefitt, which matches senior leaders with vetted executive coaches.

    Subscribe